Manager and Architect: The Evolving Journey of the CIO in the Era of Agents

In this article we discuss:

• The Shifting Landscape

• The Agent Lifecycle: Development to Retirement

• Responsible AI in Practice

• The Power of Partnership

Think back to a few years ago. Remember how quickly the role of the CIO seemed to pivot from managing servers in a data center to navigating the complexities of cloud migration? From optimizing legacy systems to championing digital transformation across the enterprise? 

Consider the factory of the 1880s, shackled to a single, monolithic steam engine. The entire business—every machine, every workflow, every worker—was physically tethered to this one central power source. The chief engineer's job was to simply keep the big engine running.

Then came electricity. Power became decentralized, fluid, and available on demand, anywhere. The genius was no longer in maintaining the central engine, but in redesigning the entire factory around a new, agile workflow. The engineer's role transformed from power maintenance to system architecture.

For many years, the CIO has been the chief engineer of the monolithic steam engines—a portfolio of digital tools like the servers, ERP, and CRM. But AI agents are electricity. They are small, intelligent motors you can deploy anywhere in the business to automate a process, answer a question, or serve a customer. The challenge is no longer just maintaining the core system. 

To truly thrive in this future, CIOs need to become the architects of a new, decentralized, and intelligent “digital factory.” CIOs need to build a model that is tested and resilient, and one that ensures collaboration, governance, and performance are in place so that trust and security are in alignment with business goals.

The Shifting Landscape

For a long time, the CIO was often seen as the guardian of an organization's digital infrastructure. Keeping the lights on, managing databases, and ensuring systems ran smoothly. But just as technology itself never stands still, neither does the CIO's role.

What's fueling this rapid shift? A few things:

1. The sheer pace of AI innovation means that AI is no longer a futuristic concept; it's here, enhancing workforce performance and powering more intuitive products and customer experiences. CIOs need to ensure that their tools and systems are ready to support AI. That means assessing your current infrastructure and making strategic investments.

2. The increasing demand for data-driven insights and decision-making across all business functions is pulling AI into the mainstream. With all eyes on data, CIOs will need to evaluate underlying data infrastructures so that AI can successfully leverage it for insights. 

3. The need for greater operational productivity and accelerated innovation is making agents indispensable for untangling complex workflows and scaling businesses. To truly achieve smooth collaboration with agents, CIOs will need to prepare for agents to work effectively alongside humans.

CIOs are uniquely positioned to meet the moment. Their deep understanding of infrastructure, data governance, and cybersecurity makes them natural leaders for this next evolution of work.   

But this is about more than adapting. CIOs have an opportunity to take charge and shape the business goals and outcomes of their organizations. If they don’t step up, their organizations risk falling behind in a competitive landscape increasingly defined by human-agent collaboration. 

That means reevaluating and determining the needs of a hybrid workforce. Below are the evolving responsibilities CIOs should consider.

Building the Trust Fabric

In this exciting new era where agents are becoming invaluable partners, the question of trust isn't just important—it's absolutely critical. 

Think about it: If we can't trust the data an AI agent uses, the decisions it makes, or even how it interacts, then the whole system falters. For CIOs, building this trust is essential. It underpins all successful human-AI collaboration.

Traditionally, we've thought of trust in terms of security, data privacy, and compliance. And yes, these are still the bedrock. CIOs must establish robust security protocols to protect agent interactions and the data they access, but the concept of trust for agents extends even further. 

It's not just about protecting data; it's about ensuring that the agents themselves are accurate, reliable, and consistent in their performance. Imagine an AI agent assisting with financial forecasting. Its accuracy and reliability directly impact strategic business decisions. 

In an interview with Deloitte’s Jannine Zucker for the Wall Street Journal, Workday CIO Rani Johnson said: 

“It’s important to take a gradual approach and build trust by helping employees understand how the technology works and any security and privacy implications. Only 52% of employees welcome AI, and 55% are confident their organization will ensure AI is implemented in a responsible and trustworthy way, according to our research. There is a trust gap.”

The challenge is closing that gap. How do CIOs ensure that an agent, given a certain level of autonomy, continues to operate within defined parameters? And how do humans remain in the loop?

CIOs will need to consider implementing continuous monitoring systems that allow humans to intervene, develop clear ethical guidelines for AI development and deployment, and foster a culture where transparent feedback is welcome. 

By actively addressing data privacy, security, compliance, and the reliability of AI, CIOs build a sturdy foundation of trust.

Orchestrating the New Digital Team

Imagine a future where your AI isn't just a tool you use, but a true collaborator. 

The key is in designing how humans and agents interact, and even how agents interact with each other, to create a harmonious and highly productive digital workforce

Consider different interaction models.  Sometimes a human might directly prompt an agent for information or action, while other times, autonomous agents might work in the background, completing tasks or collaborating with other agents to achieve a larger goal.

In agent-to-agent collaborations, one agent might handle customer service inquiries, while another AI agent specializes in technical support to provide solutions, all without a human stepping in. 

Or an agent might analyze market trends and then share its insights directly with another agent responsible for optimizing supply chain logistics. This interconnected web of intelligent agents can unlock incredible efficiencies.

But it’s critical CIOs define the role for each agent. Just as a human employee has a job description, access permissions, and a place within the company hierarchy, agents need similar boundaries. This careful planning prevents unintended consequences and maintains control, ensuring agents are true allies, not unpredictable forces. 

Best practices for human-AI collaboration involve creating clear communication channels between people and AI agents, developing feedback systems for ongoing AI improvement, and providing thorough training for employees on how to best use AI. This is where the CIO and CHRO collaborate to drive adoption, ensuring that AI agents and the human workforce are aligned, fostering a harmonious and productive environment where human ingenuity is augmented by AI.

It's about fostering an environment where humans feel empowered by AI, rather than intimidated, where agents are integrated so smoothly that they feel like an extension of the team. 

By strategically orchestrating these interactions, CIOs are creating workplaces where humans and AI can flourish together.

Measuring Success in a Hybrid Workforce

As we welcome agents into our teams, a fundamental question emerges: How do we measure the success of a hybrid workforce? 

The good news is that there’s no need to start from scratch. We can use what we know about managing people and broaden that to agents. Agents need clear roles, expectations, and ways to check their performance. The idea is that people leaders, like HR, team with CIOs to manage agents in much the same way they guide humans. Athena Karp, senior vice president of product and solutions marketing at Workday, drove this point home recently, sharing that managing these digital collaborators shouldn’t fall on the shoulders of one leader. "We need every single executive,” Karp says.

It will be important for CIOs to strategically partner with other leaders to understand emerging AI versions and deployment criteria

But measuring the success of a hybrid workforce is a unique challenge. Unlike humans, agents don't have soft skills or teamwork in the traditional sense. Instead, leaders can assess and measure how accurate they are with data, how fast they complete tasks, or how many errors they prevent. For example, an agent handling customer service might be judged by how often it solves problems and how much it helps human agents with their workload. 

New frameworks are needed to assess this partnership. This could involve looking at overall team productivity, efficiency gains attributable to the AI, or even the enhanced quality of work that results from the human-AI partnership.

Employees need to understand how AI's role impacts their own performance metrics and how the AI's contributions are being assessed. This transparency helps build trust and encourages human employees to see AI as a valuable augmenter of their skills. 

The Agent Lifecycle: Development to Retirement

Another thing to consider is the agent lifecycle, which in some ways mirrors that of employees. For CIOs that means partnering with CHROs to combine a technical approach with an HR-like approach. 

Think of an agent's lifecycle like this: 

• Attraction (problem identification): First, start by figuring out what challenges your organization faces where an agent could really make a difference. Spot those tricky spots, slow processes, or exciting new chances where an agent can bring something special to the table. Think of it this way: just like a company shares its perks to find great people, this phase is all about making the idea of an AI solution shine and attracting key stakeholders.

• Recruitment (design and development): Here the specific agent is conceptualized, designed, and developed. This involves:

  • Defining the agent's role: What specific tasks will it perform? What data will it use?

  • Algorithm selection: Choosing the appropriate machine learning models or AI techniques.

  • Data sourcing and preparation: Gathering and cleaning the necessary data for training.

  • Coding and training: Building the agent's algorithms and training it on the prepared data.

This is akin to sourcing, interviewing, and selecting the right human candidate for a role.

• Onboarding (deployment and integration): Once developed, the AI agent needs to be seamlessly integrated into the existing operational environment. This stage includes:

  • Infrastructure setup: Ensuring the necessary hardware and software infrastructure are in place.

  • System integration: Connecting the AI agent with other systems and data sources.

  • Initial testing and calibration: Running preliminary tests to ensure it functions as expected and fine-tuning its parameters

Like a new employee gets set up with tools and introduced to the team, an agent gets its operational environment ready.

• Development (learning and optimization): Agents, unlike static programs, are designed to learn and improve. This stage is continuous and involves:

  • Ongoing data feeding: Providing new data for the agent to learn from.

  • Performance monitoring: Tracking the agent's output and efficiency.

  • Algorithm refinement: Making adjustments to its algorithms based on performance data and new insights.

  • Model updates: Deploying newer, more efficient versions of the agent as technology evolves.

This mirrors an employee's continuous professional development, training, and performance reviews.

• Retention/engagement (maintenance and value delivery): To ensure an AI agent continues to provide value, it needs ongoing attention and validation. This stage focuses on:

  • Regular maintenance: Ensuring the agent's systems are healthy and secure.

  • Troubleshooting: Addressing any issues or errors that arise.

  • Value assessment: Regularly evaluating the ROI and impact the agent is having.

  • Stakeholder trust: Building and maintaining trust in the agent's decisions and outputs among users.

This is about ensuring the agent remains a valuable asset, much like retaining a skilled employee by providing a supportive environment. 

• Separation/offboarding (retirement and decommissioning): Eventually, an AI agent may reach the end of its useful life due to:

  • Obsolescence: Newer, more efficient solutions emerge.

  • Changing business needs: The problem it was designed to solve no longer exists or has changed significantly.

  • Performance decline: The agent's accuracy or efficiency decreases.

This stage involves safely decommissioning the agent, archiving its data and code, and ensuring a smooth transition to any new solutions. This is comparable to an employee leaving the company, with proper handover and exit procedures.

• Advocacy (knowledge transfer and future influence): Even after an AI agent is retired, its impact can continue. This stage involves:

  • Documenting learnings: Recording insights gained from its operation, successes, and failures.

  • Reusable components: Identifying and saving any valuable algorithms or data pipelines for future projects.

  • Best practices: Deriving best practices for future AI deployments based on the agent's performance.

Just as former employees can become advocates, the knowledge gained from a retired agent can inform and improve future AI initiatives. 

Thinking about agents this way can help organizations manage their AI investments more strategically, ensuring they are designed, developed, maintained, and retired in a structured and value-driven way.

Responsible AI in Practice

As agents become deeply embedded in organizations, the conversation inevitably turns to ethics. For CIOs, the question isn't just can we deploy this AI? The question is should we, and how do we ensure it's done responsibly?

The CIO plays a pivotal role in building and deploying responsible AI, focusing on critical ethical considerations: bias, fairness, transparency, and accountability. It’s a bit like being the ethical architect for your digital workforce, ensuring every agent is built on a foundation of integrity.

• A pressing concern in responsible AI is bias: AI systems learn from data, and if that data reflects existing societal biases, the AI can perpetuate and even amplify them. CIOs should implement robust testing protocols to identify and mitigate bias throughout the agent lifecycle. 

• Fairness and transparency go hand-in-hand: Decisions agents make should be understandable, not a black box. CIOs should advocate for systems that allow for explainability—the ability to understand why an AI made a particular decision. This transparency is crucial for building trust and enables accountability, ensuring that if an agent makes an error there's a clear path to understanding the cause.

• Human accountability is key when it comes to AI: Leaders need to set clear guidelines for who oversees AI deployment, monitors performance, addresses ethical issues, and ensures compliance. This means fostering AI literacy across the organization, helping everyone understand how these tools work, what to expect from them, and how to define and design human involvement effectively. This approach keeps human oversight at the center of AI's role in the workplace.

Beyond technical solutions, CIOs are instrumental in fostering a culture of responsible AI development and deployment. This means championing ethical guidelines, providing training to teams on responsible AI principles, and encouraging a mindset where ethical considerations are integrated from the very beginning of a project, not as an afterthought. 

By embracing this responsibility, CIOs make work better for everyone.

The Power of Partnership

In the past, the CIO, CHRO, and CFO might have operated in more siloed functions. Today, however, the rise of agents demands a collaborative synergy that makes this alliance not just beneficial, but essential. 

Karp adds, "It is more important than ever that we have that depth of connection and depth of collaboration. Because to successfully bring agents to an organization, to successfully have that human-machine collaboration, we need a number of different factors."

Shared goals around the future of work, like talent management, operational efficiency, and delivering measurable business value, are the engines that will drive successful AI integration.

• CHRO-CIO collaboration: The CHRO is the expert on the human element—the workforce. As AI reshapes jobs and skills, the CHRO's partnership with the CIO is vital for redefining work. They focus on how AI impacts employee experience, talent acquisition, training and development (upskilling for human-AI collaboration), and fostering a culture where humans and agents can thrive together. The CHRO's insights are crucial for bridging the trust gap employees have with AI.

• CFO-CIO collaboration: The CFO brings the financial rigor and focus on business value. They are instrumental in evaluating the ROI of AI initiatives, ensuring that deployments contribute directly to operational efficiency, cost savings, and ultimately, increased profitability. The CFO's perspective ensures that AI investments are not just technologically sound but also strategically aligned with the organization's financial health and growth objectives. They help quantify the benefits of enhanced productivity from human-agent teams.

When CIOs tap into these partnerships, they create a holistic strategy for AI. They can collectively address how agents will impact the organization, ensuring agent deployment transforms people and processes, creating a more agile and innovative enterprise.

Guiding the Future of Work

As the CIO's role evolves, it demands new considerations. The modern CIO needs to build trust for AI, foster seamless human-agent collaboration, and adapt performance management.

CIOs oversee the entire agent lifecycle, from development to responsible retirement, navigating unique challenges. And champion responsible AI to address bias, fairness, and transparency.

The agentic CIO is truly a strategic architect, building the very foundation for a more intelligent, collaborative, and human-centric future of work. It’s an exciting time to be at the helm of technology, shaping how humans and AI can achieve extraordinary things together.

With insights from over 2,300 leaders, download this report to learn why 98 percent of CEOs foresee immediate benefits from implementing AI and the potential it could bring to your organization.